A new study by RMIT University has found smart home control devices may actually increase energy use rather than cutting it, with households using them more for lifestyle benefits than to save power.
Funded by Energy Consumers Australia, the study gave 46 households the opportunity to try some market-leading smart home control devices, such as light bulbs and plugs that are controlled from a smart phone.
Despite the energy sector advocating smart home control technology as a way to help households manage their power consumption, lead author Dr Larissa Nicholls says the research shows these devices are not necessarily the answer to energy management.
“Trial participants found they it was not as simple as taking the devices out of the box, plugging them in and downloading the app,” Nicholls, from the RMIT Centre for Urban Research, said.
“There was a range of usability issues which led to half the participants either not trying or failing to successfully install the devices.
“Failed installations were not just foiled by the devices themselves or lack of user persistence or knowledge.
“Smartphone compatibility issues, unreliable WiFi, forgotten passwords, app problems, and concern over requests to supply personal information were all given as reasons why some householders gave up trying.
“Those who gave up using the devices did so because they didn’t find them useful or convenient for their household.”
In terms of energy management, project lead investigator Dr Yolande Strengers said participants made either limited or no use of devices to manage their energy use.
“We found that households were more interested in using smart home control for lifestyle improvements – such as turning the heater on before they got home and using extra lighting for personal safety or home security – rather than to save or shift energy demand in the home,” she said.
Strengers says the findings of the study, Smart Home Control: Exploring the potential for off-the-shelf enabling technologies in energy vulnerable and other households, call for more caution in how smart home control is promoted by the energy sector.
“Mainstream marketing of these devices could undermine the energy sector’s ambitions for home control devices,” she said.
“We need to be realistic about how smart home control products are marketed, how the media influences the way the products are used, and how the other benefits of smart home control may affect home energy consumption.”